Free rate comparisons & quotes · No obligationQuestions? Email support@repairrates.co
Home › Guides › Project guides
Project guides

Roof repair vs. replacement: how to decide

Age, damage extent and what's under the shingles. A simple framework, with typical costs.

DWDana Whitfield, Senior Editor · Updated Sep 9, 2026 · 7 min read

A roof is the most expensive single item most homeowners ever replace, so it's worth knowing when a repair will do.

Repair usually makes sense when

  • The roof is less than about 15 years old (asphalt)
  • Damage is limited to one area: a few missing shingles, a flashing leak, a damaged vent boot
  • The decking underneath is solid

Typical repair costs range from about $380 to $1,850 nationally.

Replacement usually makes sense when

  • Asphalt shingles are 20+ years old, curling, or losing granules
  • Leaks are appearing in multiple places
  • Decking is soft or sagging
  • Repairs would cover more than about 30% of the roof

A full asphalt replacement typically runs $8,500 to $17,500 for an average home. Metal and tile cost significantly more.

Check your insurance first

If damage came from a storm, call your insurer before signing with a roofer. Many policies pay replacement cost minus depreciation. Get a contractor to meet the adjuster on site.

Ready to compare quotes?
See local rates for your project in 30 seconds.
0 selected